Page 219 - ibdaa

Ÿ-b<¡~9¡EH Ÿ-bJxƒF ˆ*]+(°* 218

‡+b~zD* –~|ŒD*

¢•< ¥¡€›J ¥wD* 4b~¦D* ˆ*]+(°* œ£+H " ŠF4¡+ " ™žŒ~8H œJwD* œ£~6H¡ž˜D* œ£+ ‘xŒD* ¡G *wGH bžD f˜£B ° fDb~8&°*
d£< œ< bK ~¦J&* " ŠF4¡+ " l]p- b˜C fŒJx~{D* x£= H&* fŒ£›†D* ib<¡˜m˜D* ]›< A ,2¡/¡E f˜£B ¤GH f˜£D* œE $¤~7
H2 d~zpA ™Gx£= 4b’A*& ¡~zcgJ 6b›D* ¦†+ *& ¢D(* x£~{J ¥wD* Plagiarism 4b’A&°* —bpgF* ¡GH °*& fDb~8&°* ¤A šb<

6bcgB(°* 4]~|E ¢D*( ,4b~7(°*

ŸFbE5 c~6 ¥xc<

A GENIUS AHEAD OF HIS OR HER TIME?

"ŠF4¡+" kp+ œE Ix1&* ,xE b›G zcgF œpFH x~|†D* rH4 x.*& ¢•< *K x~7'¡E bžD¡~|0 –cB ibAb~{gC°b+ ¡' c›gD* ]†J ]B
*& *4K *x’-H *4K *xE hc. ]A ŸFb~¦g0° bK _£žE bEyD* qc~|J ¢g0 ]J]/ Žb~{gC* ¢D*( –~8¡gD* 4]›J " Ÿ£A $b/ ¥wD* ™ž•˜D*
8 "Žb~{gCÉD b_K £žE bEyD* 4b~8 bE]›< bpKM Jx~8 ¡' c›gD* *wG qc~8&* ™. ŽM bC x£= –’~{+ (*H Žb~{gC°b+ b& c›- b~zF°( *
,x’A ™›- ]A "ŸFbE5 c~zJ ¥xc< ¢˜~zJ bE ]/¡J ° " —¡D* ¢D*( x1*% kp+ ¤A "ixcD*& " |•1 *wG –/&* œE
bK _£~7 hFbCH x~|†D* “D3 rH4 œE *K $y/ hFbC *3(* °*( bž+ Žxg†J ]0*& ° œ’DH bE fJxc< œ< ¤<*]+*( ˆ*xg1* H&* f†£A4 f£<*]+*(

™ž+bm<*( H 6b›D* xJ]- x£jJ

ibƒŒp- ”b›G œ’DH ¤<*]+(°* $¤~{•D ib<b˜mD* H&* ¡˜’QP p˜D* bG2]pJ ¤gD* ib˜~zD* ¢•< *wG ˆ*]+°( * 4¡ƒ›E ]˜g†JH
zEbsD* –~|ŒD* ¤A b›J*& 4 b˜C ¥x’ŒD* bm-°* *wG ¢•<

""ˆ]c˜D* ¡G œE "—*¡' ~zD* f=b£~8 “D3 –/*& œE 2b<b& A Hy†D* &b~{+ fž+b~{E ,xƒF " ¤Dbž£˜gFy’£~6 " ¢›c- ]BH
2xŒD* I]D f£<*]+(°* 2¡žmD* &b~{›- £C b›D ~|- bžF&° ™ƒ›D* fJxƒF ¢•< ˆ*]+É( D ŸŒ~8H š¡JH ""ˆ*]+°( * ‡J œJ&*" Ÿ•†/H
–pD* “D3 ¤A ¡•˜†J œJwD* 6b›D* ¢•<H œ£†E –0 ¤A x£.b& gDb+ xE&°* x1%* ¤A *& ]c- ¢g0 fJ*]cD* ¤A fC4]E ¡’- ° bž›’DH
x£‰gJ bE]›<H ™£˜~|gD* H*& ib£~9bJxD* H&* œŒD* H&* $bJy£ŒD* –jE ¤Ax†˜D* —bm˜D* H&* fAx†˜D* –0 œ£†E —bmE ¤A ™. œEH
f0bg˜D* ibE¡•†˜D* *( —bm˜D* “D3 ¤A i&*x: ¤gD* ,]J]mD* 4b’A°& * ‡E A*¡g- fJx€+ Hx’Œ£A b~¦K J*& 2*xA&°* x£‰gJ —bm˜D*

x~|†D* rH4 œE *K $y/ bG4bcg<* œ’˜J —bm˜D* 4b:*( ¤A

œE*ygD*H ,4x’g˜D* ibAb~{gC°*

MULTIPLE DISCOVERIES AND SIMULTANEITIES

œE*ygD*" ,4bc†+ "ŠF4¡+" bžŒ~8H ¤gD* ,4x’g˜D* ibAb~{gC°*H fCxg~{˜D* i*4b~|cg~6°* ¤A x~|†D* rH4 4H2 q~¦gJ
f›E*yg˜D* H&* ,4x’g˜D* ibAb~{gC°* (bA f£˜~zgD* hFbC b˜žEH near-simultaneities/near-sychronisms "e4bg˜D*
&* ¤›†J *wGH ,4Hx~¦Db+ b†K E *¡•˜†J *& H2 *]K 0*H ¡’J 2b’J hBH ¤A bE bK _£~7 xjC&* H*& b~|s~7 ~{g’J bE]›< l]p-
¦Bb›- ,x’ŒD* wG œ’D œ£†E —bmE ¤A –˜†J |s~7 ¥&* ]J ¢•< f›’˜E ¤žA ¤DbgDb+H x~|†D* rH4 œE $y/ ibAb~{gC°*
fcG¡˜D* œE *]K / f£Db< f/4]+ ¡†g˜gJ œJwD* 8bs~7°& * ¦†+ i*4]B ¢D(* ˆ*xg1°* –~¦A Hy†- ¤gD* ™£ƒ†D* |s~{D* fJxƒF

f•jE°& bA f£˜~zgD* hFbC b˜žEH f›E*ygE bK Fb£0&*H ,4x’gE ibAb~{gC* ¢<]- bK Fb£0*& ¤GH *]K / ,x£jC f›E*yg˜D* ibAb~{gC°* *(
"ŠF4¡+" ÉK g~zEH bK ›E*ygE bAK b~{gC* œ£†+4*& H f£Fb˜.H f)bE (Ogbun & Thomas, 1962) " 6bE¡-H xc=H&* " bž›E ,x£jC
—H]/ œ£cJH f•jE°& * “•- œE f•J¡: f˜)bB *xK 1'¡E (Lamb &Easton, 1984) œg~zJ*( H dE° ]Q <*& H 8

,x£ž~{D* ibAb~{gC°* “•- ¦†+